Food, Global Health 4 min
CiTIQUE, citizens making an invaluable contribution
CiTIQUE is a participatory research programme seeking to better understand tick ecology and tick-borne diseases in an effort to improve disease prevention. It is the first recipient in the Crowdsourcing category of the newly created INRAE Prize for Participatory Research.
Published on 21 February 2022
CiTIQUE is made up of three parts: an app where users record tick bites and tick bites on their pets; a tick library — the only one of its kind in Europe — where users can send the ticks they’ve been bitten by for further analysis; and a database to link all the different information together. The data give particular insight into when and where tick bites occur and which diseases (viruses, bacteria) they carry.
What citizens bring to research
In sending the ticks that have bitten them, citizens are making a unique contribution to our understanding of the risks associated with ticks. “These are data that we cannot acquire in another way,” says Pascale Frey-Klett, the programme’s co-founder with Jean-François Cosson (1). “We know how to collect ticks in nature, but there is no way to get information about tick bites other than through the participation of citizens. Since the start of the project in 2017, the data collected have proven very useful in prevention efforts. In particular, we have seen that 25% of reported tick bites happen in the garden, and 4% happen in the home. Risk in these situations is underestimated, and few people think to protect themselves from ticks when they are in their own homes.”
Another way of doing research
Citizen contributions go well beyond sending in ticks for analysis. Since the beginning of the CiTIQUE project, researchers have welcomed participants from all backgrounds in a dedicated laboratory (2) to participate in research training courses in real conditions that have led to new scientific findings. One such finding, that came to light following a number of training course cycles, was that the data showed that pets were a likely contributing factor in tick bites that occurred around the home. “The trainees themselves had raised the question,” says Jonas Durand, who has been overseeing CITIQUE training courses since 2019. “It’s a question they were able to also answer themselves by following a rigorous and exacting scientific process. They first identified the tick species in the samples in the tick library that had bitten dogs and cats, and noted that these species also bit humans. They then searched ticks for the bacteria that causes Lyme disease. Data from 21 training course cohorts with more than 300 participants made it possible to calculate that around 6% of dog-biting ticks, and 15% of cat-biting ticks carried the bacteria that causes Lyme disease. This important finding highlights the need for heightened protection of pets against ticks, and will lead to a scientific publication.”
“I didn’t know it took so long and that it was so difficult to find answers” Marie, age 11
Citizen scientists contribute new ideas, and many are keen on experimentation. “We’re in direct contact with the citizens and try to respond to the questions they send us,” says Pascale Frey-Klett. “We worked together with one person who wanted to test a system in her garden using tubes lined with cotton wool treated with tick repellent to prevent the spread of ticks via small rodents. Together, we developed a rigorous protocol for counting ticks in order to test the effectiveness of the system.”
CiTIQUE’s scale — with more than 70,000 tick reports and 50,000 ticks preserved in the tick library — also led to other significant findings. In human tick bites, 30% of ticks carried at least one disease pathogen. It is worth noting, however, that a tick bite does not automatically mean a person will become ill. Ticks transmit pathogens via their saliva; the process is complex and depends notably on the duration of the bite.
CiTIQUE also developed the first map of the risk of tick bites in France (read the article: Mapping the risk of tick bites in France [in French]).
Researchers working with citizens
“Since the information we receive is reliable, and I’ve understood it and tested it, I’m in a good position to transmit the information to others” Corinne, age 48
“Our interactions with citizens provide support and clear scientific information on ticks, and offer reassurances to people who may be concerned and receiving conflicting information, particularly about Lyme disease (3),” says Pascale Frey-Klett. “We sometimes challenge conventional wisdom, such as the idea that a person can know if they’ve been infected by testing the tick that bit them (4). If a tick bears a pathogen, it does not necessarily transmit it with a bite. At the same time, the absence of a pathogen should not reassure a person either, given that it is not possible to test every tick that is sent in. For that reason, we don’t send personalised responses to the people who send in tick samples. We do, however, offer clear prevention advice: remove the tick as soon as possible and do not use products, such as alcohol or soap, that put stress on the tick and may trigger the transmission of pathogens the tick may be carrying.”
CiTIQUE’s primary function is as a long-term observatory for tick ecology and tick-borne diseases, their distribution in France and the impact of climate change on these. In particular, the movement of invasive species, such as Hyalomma marginatum, into new areas is being monitored in collaboration with the French Agricultural Research Centre for International Development (CIRAD) (read the article: New tick species and tick-borne diseases found in France [in French]).
The data that CiTIQUE generates also serve as a springboard for a number of other research projects. Through CiTIQUE, it was possible to monitor Lyme disease symptoms from a cohort of people who had possibly been exposed to the disease, and to develop a monitoring questionnaire (see Ohticks project [in French]). CiTIQUE was also able to make a contribution in the field of social sciences through a Master’s research project showing that participating in CiTIQUE had an impact on feelings of empowerment and the construction of a positive social identity in young people aged 12 on average.
Partnerships and representatives: keys to success
“At the start of the project in 2017 to 2019, together with Jean-François Cosson, we were proactive in promoting CiTIQUE. We met with associations, participated in the Paris International Agricultural Show, engaged with the press, and so on. We also drew on the Nancy-Champenoux Permanent Centre for Environmental Initiatives (CPIE [in French])(5) to help promote the project,” says Pascale Frey-Klett. “Very quickly, the project grew, and now it’s our partners that come to us.”
Irene Carravieri, who initially worked at INRAE and since moved to the Nancy-Champenoux CPIE, manages the tick library and CiTIQUE’s many partnerships. “It’s a really strong network with CiTIQUE at the hub. We recently, for example, reached a partnership agreement with France’s National Forest Ownership Centre (CNPF [in French]) and the National Forest Office (ONF [in French]) to promote tick-bite prevention in forestry workers who are particularly exposed to tick bites. We also work with healthcare professionals, such as pharmacists, doctors and veterinarians, to raise awareness of the work of CiTIQUE and to promote tick-bite prevention. We also train volunteers to act as CiTIQUE representatives in different regions of France.”
A programme in constant evolution
CiTIQUE began as a regional project with regional funding; it now operates on a national scale. A parliamentary report on France’s national plan for Lyme diseases highlighted the value of CiTIQUE’s work in 2021, and CiTIQUE’s support to public and health policy is widely recognised. “We are in contact with the Ministry of Health to secure the necessary means to pursue and strengthen the programme, whose scope now goes beyond research alone,” says Pascale Frey-Klett.
- Jean-François Cosson passed away in 2019.
- The Tous Chercheurs [Every Researcher] Laboratory at INRAE Grand Est–Nancy, established with the Tous chercheurs association.
- Article: Lyme disease in 10 questions (in French).
- Article in The Conversation (in French).
- Around 80 CPIEs throughout France organise environmental-awareness initiatives.
- July 2017: CiTIQUE established, and Signalement TIQUE smartphone app launched
- July 2018 and September 2021: partnership agreements with ONF and CNPF respectively to promote tick-bite prevention in forestry workers
- March 2019: first research training courses with school pupils and citizens at the Tous Cherchers Laboratory at INRA Grand Est–Nancy
- May 2020: updated version of the Signalement TIQUE app released. The new version is able to connect bite reports (place, date) with ticks preserved in the tick library.
- Partnerships formed with businesses to test the effectiveness of tick repellents
- Daily tick-bite reports, tick samples for the library and correspondence sharing experiences
Lead: INRAE and the ARBRE Laboratory of Excellence. Partners and stakeholders: University of Lorraine, ANSES, CPIE Nancy-Champenoux, Tous Chercheurs association, local governments, the general public, people exposed to tick-bite risk, human and animal healthcare professionals
About the award
The Prize for Participatory Research was established by INRAE in 2021 under the aegis of the French Ministry of Higher Education, Research and Innovation as a part of new legislation on research programming. The Prize will highlight research projects that bring together scientists and non-scientists, be it to collect data or with direct involvement in the research process itself. Read the article (in French).