Food, Global Health 3 min

Reduce the carbon footprint of food, but not at any price!

PRESS RELEASE - How can the carbon footprint of our food habits be reduced while still maintaining nutritionally adequate and acceptable diets in cultural and economic terms? With sustainable diets in mind, INRA researchers teamed up with Aix-Marseille University to show, via a study using models, that it is indeed possible to cut back on greenhouse gas emissions while maintaining nutritional value. It all depends on smart food choices: more starchy foods, more fruits and vegetables, and less meat. Their findings have been published in Public Health Nutrition.

Published on 15 April 2016

illustration Reduce the carbon footprint of food, but not at any price!

According to the FAO, a sustainable diet is one that has little impact on the environment, is nutritionally adequate, culturally acceptable, and affordable. But are these criteria compatible? Researchers from INRA and the Aix-Marseille University1 have simulated the impact of cutting back on the greenhouse gases (GHG) of diets on nutritional quality and price.

To conduct this model-based research, scientists used data gathered from the French INCA2 study2 on the consumption of 1,899 adults. They crossed those figures with data on the carbon footprint of 402 of the most popular foodstuffs in France, the average price of each foodstuff, and indicators of its nutritional quality. The researchers defined and analysed three types of models:

  • the first imposed no nutritional constraints (FREE), the only requirement being a gradual decline in greenhouse gas emissions with no change in calorie intake;
  • the second model imposed a reduction in greenhouse emissions and maintenance of the macronutrient balance: proteins, lipids, carbohydrates (MACRO);
  • lastly, a nutritionally adequate model (ADEQ) imposed not only an equilibrium of macronutrients but also maintaining the recommended dietary allowances in vitamins, minerals, trace elements, fibre, and essential fatty acids, and maximum recommended values for sodium, saturated fat, and free sugars.

The scientists found that with the FREE and MACRO models, the reduction in greenhouse gas emissions of more than 30% lowered the price of modelled consumption, but took a toll on nutritional quality.
This goes to show that compliance with recommendations on macronutrients is not enough to guarantee nutritional quality. It is the ADEQ model that will generate nutritionally adequate consumption while ensuring that greenhouse gas emissions are steadily decreased:

  • For nutritional needs to be met, there must be an immediate increase in the quantity of fruits and vegetables consumed.
  • To reduce greenhouse gas emissions while maintaining the nutritional value of diets, the quantity of meat, and especially the meat of grazing animals and delicatessen meats, must be gradually diminished.
  • Lastly, to reduce greenhouse gas emissions by more than 40%, meat and dishes containing meat must be entirely phased out, and the amount of starchy foods (potato and grains) increased. It is even feasible, in theory, to reach a 60% reduction in greenhouse gas emissions with the ADEQ model. But social acceptability, which is a cornerstone of sustainable diets, risks being seriously undermined, as the consumption proposed here is a far cry from established norms.

This study therefore reveals that nutritional quality must be taken into careful consideration and recognised as a key indicator when it comes to boosting the sustainability of diets. Since sustainable diets must also be realistic diets, a 30% cut in greenhouse gases seems a reasonable goal, attainable through better food choices. Improving food production and transforming food systems are also avenues that should be explored, to further cut back on the environmental impact of human food consumption.

1This study was financed by the French National Research Agency’s OCAD project (Offrir et Consommer une Alimentation Durable) on sustainable diets, and by the Daniel and Nina Carasso foundation, within the framework of the AVASUN project (assessing the bio-availability of nutrients in sustainable diets).
2Individual and national study on food consumption, carried out in France in 2006-2007.

INRAE news office

Scientific contacts

Nicole Darmon Scientific directorJoint Research Unit for Nutrition, Obesity and Thrombotoc Risks



Learn more

Food, Global Health

Suivi de la qualité nutritionnelle de l’offre alimentaire en France : signature d’une nouvelle convention-cadre de l’Oqali pour la période 2020-2023

COMMUNIQUE DE PRESSE - L’Anses, l’Inra et les ministères en charge de la santé, la consommation et l’alimentation ont signé ce mercredi 11 décembre la nouvelle convention-cadre de l’observatoire de l’alimentation (Oqali) pour la période 2020-2023. L’Observatoire poursuit et renforce ainsi ses missions de suivi de la qualité de l’offre nutritionnelle des produits transformés afin d’appuyer les politiques publiques en matière d’alimentation.

19 December 2019

Food, Global Health

Six infographies pour comprendre notre alimentation

DOSSIER - Les enjeux d'une alimentation saine et durable sont multiples. Il s'agit d'étudier quel régime alimentaire serait à la fois favorable à notre santé et durable pour la planète. Plusieurs leviers sont identifiés : réduire le gaspillage alimentaire, développer une nouvelle politique de prix ou encore l’étiquetage nutritionnel. On fait le point en images et en chiffres.

19 December 2019