Agroecology 3 min

Winter rapeseed – the benefits of its association with companion legumes

As a possible agroecological alternative to synthetic inputs, associating companion legumes with winter rapeseed crops enables a global reduction in weed pressure without reducing crop yield. A promising practice whose sustainability deserves further evaluation.

Published on 11 January 2018

illustration Winter rapeseed – the benefits of its association with companion legumes
© INRAE, MAITRE Christophe

The evolution of agriculture towards sustainability notably requires the implementation of new practices that can limit the use of synthetic pesticides and fertilisers. These practices also include the association of a cash crop with companion plants that are not harvested.

Widely cultivated in the northern hemisphere, rapeseed remains susceptible to insects and competition from weeds. INRA scientists and their colleagues have evaluated the effects of its association with different companion plants on the encroachment of plots, nitrogen nutrition and the yields of winter rapeseed crops, and analysed their sources of variability.

In practice, they compared 79 open-field trials combining winter rapeseed and companion legumes. These trials covered a broad range of pedoclimatic conditions and cultivation practices in the north-western half of France.

Rapeseed and companion legumes, a winning combination…

Sown at the same time at the end of summer, the rapeseed crop and its companion plants grew together during the autumn until the winter frosts. The companion legumes were susceptible to frost so they might be destroyed naturally by the cold during winter.

During the autumn growth phase, the rapeseed and companion plants, but also weeds, competed for nutrients and light. The rapeseed was less affected by this competition when the companion plants were legumes because the latter competed less for nitrogen due to their ability to fix atmospheric nitrogen.

At the start of winter, the presence of companion plants enabled a reduction in weed biomass of between 38% and 52%, without any species appearing to be more efficient than another. At harvest, non-legume companion plants had reduced the rapeseed yield (580 kg/hectare less than with rapeseed alone), but on the other hand, companion legumes such as field bean alone or in a mixture with lentil, caused an increase in this yield of between 160 and 120 kg/hectare.

Field bean, lentil or a mixture of the two also enabled a reduction in nitrate inputs of up to 25% (30-40 kg/hectare) without the crop yield diminishing significantly.

… whatever the cultivation or environmental conditions

The performance of each of the companion plant species was generally little dependent on the conditions prevailing during the trials, thus underlining the validity of the results in a broad range of cultivation and environmental conditions.

All these results showed that the cultivation of rapeseed in the presence of non-harvested companion legumes is a promising practice, particularly on nitrogen-poor soils; field bean alone or mixed with lentil displayed the best overall performance. Further studies now need to be undertaken to precisely evaluate the socioeconomic and environmental value of using companion plants, so as to prove the sustainability of this practice.



Verret V., Gardarin A., Makowski D., Lorin M S., Butier A., & Valantin-Morison M. (2017). Assessment of the benefits of frost-sensitive companion plants in winter rapeseed. European Journal of Agronomy 9: 93. 10.1016/j.eja.2017.09.006.


Catherine Foucaud-Scheunemanntranslated by Victoria Hawken


Muriel Valantin-Morison Agronomy Joint Research Unit (INRAE, AgroParisTech)



Learn more


Three questions for a springing sprout: Mycophyto

Water and soil pollution, resistant pests, dwindling biodiversity… the adverse effects of pesticides on the environment are well-known. But what if we used natural synergies between plants and the micro-organisms that live in soil to ease through the agricultural transition? Mycophyto, a young start-up based in Sophia Antipolis, proposes effective biological alternatives for farming and landscaping. We sat down to talk with Justine Lipuma, co-founder of Mycophyto.

23 April 2019


Can organic farming manage without copper?

On 16 January 2018, INRAE presented the findings of a collective scientific expert report (ESCo) on the levers available to reduce the use of copper to protect organic crops. This expert report had been commissioned by the French Institute for Organic Farming (ITAB) and an INRAE federative research programme (the SMaCH metaprogramme). The approach of the ESCo involved an examination of the literature, and the results obtained could potentially be applied to other types of agriculture seeking to limit or eliminate the consumption of certain inputs.

16 January 2018


WeedElec, from "haute couture" to cutting-edge weeding

Launched at the beginning of 2018 under the aegis of 5 partners – including the EMMAH Joint Research Unit under the joint supervision of INRA and IRSTEA – the WeedElec project combines robots and drones for the detection and control of weeds using electric current. Claude Doussan is a researcher at INRAE Avignon, and presents its genesis and development.

17 December 2019