How AI can help identify bees exposed to pesticides

PRESS RELEASE - Researchers at INRAE and the National Autonomous University of Mexico have combined flight activity data for honey bees with AI modelling to create a high performing toxicovigilance tool. The results of their study, published in Ecological Informatics, confirm that the tool can alert users to risks to honey bee populations caused by exposure to neurotoxic pesticides.

Published on 11 July 2024

© INRAE - Christophe Maître

Honey bees, as major pollinators of crops and wild plants, are frequently exposed to multiple chemical pesticides in the environment. This regular exposure affects their behaviour and their health 1, leading to the potential loss of honey bee colonies.  One current research challenge is to arrive at an efficient and accurate assessment of the impacts of pesticides on these bees.  

To achieve this, high-tech systems are now being deployed by scientists to monitor the activity of foraging honey bees. Placed at the entrance of the hive, detectors enable the detailed measurement of flight-related traits in bees that have been individually tagged by researchers using RFID (radio frequency identification) or QR codes attached to the thorax.

Previous studies have demonstrated that multiple neurotoxic pesticides at sublethal doses (which do not kill the bee), reduce the daily flight activity of honey bees by around 25%. These findings allowed the authors of the present study to select flight reduction as an indicator of the presence of neurotoxic pesticides in the environment.

99% classification accuracy

INRAE’s research team and their colleagues from the National Autonomous University of Mexico have achieved a first, by collecting honey bee flight activity data and processing it using AI modelling. Their results made it possible to classify bee flight performance and thereby determine, as a function of the number of flights and time spent foraging outside the hive, whether the bees had been exposed or not to chemical pesticides.

For the study, a dataset of 42,092 flight records from 1107 control and 1689 exposed bees was analysed by the research team. The model achieved 99% classification accuracy when it was trained on 25 days of activity data.  

The near-perfect accuracy of the results underscores the highly predictive performance of AI models for toxicovigilance. This new technology, which must next undergo field tests, has the potential to provide real-time data for the assessment of risks linked to pesticides in honey bees. 

Olivares-Pinto U., Alaux C. et al. (2024). Using honey bee flight activity data and a deep learning model as a toxicovigilance tool. Ecological Informatics, DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ecoinf.2024.102653

Learn more

Agroecology

Hygienic honey bees are more resistant to destructive parasite

PRESS RELEASE - The parasitic mite Varroa destructor is a serious threat to honey bees, capable of decimating entire colonies. Identified as one of the causes behind the disappearance of bees around the world, this parasite is the focus of specific control measures integrated into France’s 2020 Pollinator Plan. By analysing the honey bees’ behavioural defences against this parasite, researchers from INRAE, the CNRS, the University of Rennes 1 and the University of Otago in New Zealand have discovered that varroa-infested brood emit a combination of molecules that trigger hygienic behaviour in some honey bees—piercing and cleaning contaminated brood cells—which allows them to preserve the colony. Their results, published on January 25th in Nature Chemical Biology, open up new possibilities in the fight against Varroa destructor, with the development of tests that should allow beekeepers to select the most resistant colonies.

25 January 2021

Biodiversity

World food security affected by a shortage of pollinating insects

PRESS RELEASE - Crops that are pollinated by insects provide over a third of what the world eats. An international team involving INRA has revealed that increasing the quantity and variety of pollinating insects can increase crop yields by over 20% at the international level. These results, the product of a vast study conducted in 12 countries over a five-year period, appear in the 22 January 2016 edition of Science. The study highlights the importance of ecological intensification in agriculture in improving world food security and protecting pollinating insects and biodiversity.

06 April 2020

Biodiversity

Bee pollination boosts the profitability of oilseed rape

PRESS RELEASE - Researchers from INRA and CNRS have shown for the first time that bee pollination surpasses the use of pesticides in yield and especially in profitability of oilseed rape. The team of researchers analysed data collected over four years in farmers’ fields in an agricultural plain in Deux-Sèvres (Nouvelle Aquitaine, western France). This study was published in Proceedings of the Royal Society London B on 9 October 2019.

20 December 2019